FICTIONAL DEMONSTRATION. Every name, party, vehicle, document, number, and image on this page is invented. This is a template exemplar from the lemon-case-file method.

The Meridian EV Case — Timeline & Defect History

2024 Acme Meridian EV · VIN ACME00DEMO000000 · Repurchase review case #00-DEMO (fictional)
In brief

The owners have reported the same three problems — the displays going dark while driving, a rear door latch that fails to open, and charging faults — since July 2024, four months after purchase. Acme's dealers have serviced the vehicle six times: two visits closed “could not verify” or “working as designed,” and every part that was replaced has had its symptom recur, at 10, 43, and 83 days. A federal safety recall for the display defect was filed in May 2025, but no remedy existed for five months, during which the vehicle sat at the dealership 84 days. The displays went dark again 83 days after the recall remedy was performed.

What the owners are asking for: that Acme Motors repurchase this vehicle. A written decision is expected by June 30, 2026 (fictional).

The record, 2024–2026

The most serious failure came first. On July 6, 2024, while driving at roughly 40 mph, the instrument cluster — the screen behind the steering wheel that carries the speedometer, battery level, and safety warnings — went dark, and the center screen went dark with it. The owners reported it in writing the same day. The dealership kept the car two days and closed the repair order “could not verify customer concern” (RO410221). Thirty-eight days later the owners filmed the same failure (#012).

Each subsequent problem followed the same shape: a written report, a “could not verify” or “working as designed” visit, and a dated recording of the symptom recurring. When federal recall 25V-987 confirmed the display defect across the model line in May 2025, no fix existed: Acme's own notice told dealers “no repair available.” The car waited at the dealership from August 20 to November 12, 2025 — 84 days, of which 51 passed before a remedy existed at all. The recall software was performed November 12, 2025. On February 3, 2026 — 83 days later — the cluster went dark again while driving (#048).

Component ledger — what was done, in their words, and what recurred

DateROComponent — action & their stated basisRecurred
Jul 8–9, 2024RO410221Displays / instrument cluster — Inspected; software reset
Their stated basis: “could not verify customer concern”
Yes — Aug 14, 2024 (#012)
Sep 20, 2024RO412876Door latch, driver rear — Inspected
Their stated basis: “working as designed”
Yes — Oct 2, 2024 (#019)
Dec 9–11, 2024RO415502Charge-port latch — Replaced
Their stated basis: “concern verified, fault codes stored”
Yes — Dec 21, 2024 (#027)
Aug 20 – Nov 12, 2025RO421339Displays — recall 25V-987 — Recall software performed (day 84)
Their stated basis: “remedy per recall bulletin”
Yes — Feb 3, 2026 (#048)
Mar 3–6, 2026RO427710Door latch, driver rear — Latch assembly replaced
Their stated basis: “internal malfunction”
Yes — Apr 18, 2026 (#059)

Timeline

Hover any mark; click for detail. Top bar: recall, from federal filing to the work on this car (white tick: the remedy became available). Middle: at the dealership. Bottom ticks: owner reports and dated captures.

Safety recall — federal filing → work on this carVehicle at the dealershipManufacturer publicationsOwner — reports & evidence20252026

Exemplar recordings

placeholder — a real case file streams the actual clip here
Cluster dark at speed; infotainment rebootingAugust 14, 2024 · 38 days after the first written displays report — RO410221 closed 'could not verify'
placeholder — a real case file streams the actual clip here
Connector locked in charge portDecember 21, 2024 · 10 days after RO415502 replaced the charge-port latch
placeholder — a real case file streams the actual clip here
Cluster blackout while drivingFebruary 3, 2026 · 83 days after the recall 25V-987 remedy was performed

The full record — 61 dated captures and 14 documents (sample shown)

AllDisplays Door latchCharging Documents
2024
PurchaseROTSBRORO
2025
RecallDealer commRORO
2026
ROPositionDemand

Diagnostic records requested

The request. For each problem, the manufacturer has been asked to produce its diagnostic session logs, stored fault memory, and telematics for the full calendar day of each of the 58 recorded incident timestamps (Displays — 21 · Door latch — 14 · Charging — 17 · Other electrical — 6), the complete logs from every service visit, and to treat any fault found in those records as having been reported by the owners. The request document (placeholder PDF).

Downloads

▤ The case file (PDF) — placeholder ▤ Diagnostic-records request — placeholder